Exploring Unconventional Payment Methods Around the World
Posted on By Donna Johnson
Have you been considering expanding into global markets? Have you ever thought about the cultural and societal norms that shape payment methods in different regions? Given the range of payment systems around the world that differ from what you might consider the status quo, expanding your perspectives and researching different markets and cultures, you can position your business for greater success.
In today's financial landscape, the diversity of payment methods reflects unique cultural, technological, and societal influences. While the US primarily relies on high-tech methods of digital payments, other regions utilize a mix of traditional and innovative payment practices. Some interesting methods include the Hundi system in South Asia, the cash-based economy in Germany, and cryptocurrency adoption in El Salvador.
Hundi System
The Hundi system, deeply rooted in South Asian culture, serves as an informal value transfer method that relies on trust and community networks. Unlike for example, Point of Sale systems prevalent in the US, the Hundi system operates on handwritten notes or verbal agreements, with transactions facilitated by brokers based on mutual trust.
Although the Hundi system lacks regulation and transparency, posing potential risks, it serves as a practical alternative in more remote areas. Hundis are often well-established and serve as primary mechanisms for Myanmar migrant workers and businesses abroad to move money into, out of, and within the country.
Because Hundi networks frequently operate along ethnic, religious, and social lines, trust plays a central role. This reliance on trust can pose challenges for international businesses trying to establish new relationships quickly, especially during periods of political and economic uncertainty.
Cash-based Economy in Germany
Germany is known for its strong preference for cash transactions. Despite the availability of digital payment options, many Germans prefer paying in cash for everyday purchases. This cultural attitude towards privacy and security contrasts with the US, where credit and debit card payments are more prevalent. Germany's banking system and digital payment infrastructure are like the US’, but German consumers still have a strong preference for cash.
As Foreign Policy notes, “an obsession with privacy, mistrust of big-tech and fintech in general, and worries about political and financial crises depleting bank balances overnight—an experience rooted in history as well as a cultural desire for control—all contribute to the country’s love for cash” (Vohra, 2023).
This mistrust can be traced back to Germany’s historical roots and is partially informed by the German currency crisis of 1931, highlighting how deeply ingrained cultural values and historical experiences can shape financial behaviors. This illustrates that convenience is not always the primary driver in payment preferences.
Cryptocurrency in El Salvador
El Salvador made headlines by adopting Bitcoin as legal tender in 2021, allowing citizens to use cryptocurrency for everyday transactions alongside the US dollar. This move towards financial innovation contrasts with the US, where cryptocurrencies are recognized but not treated as legal tender.
In El Salvador, the government's push for Bitcoin adoption aimed to enhance financial innovation and reduce reliance on traditional banking systems. However, the implementation was less than ideal. According to Science Advisor, "After El Salvador adopted the cryptocurrency bitcoin as legal tender, its government incentivized it with the Chivo Wallet app, a digital wallet backed by their central banking system . . . Salvadorans’ preference for tangible cash and, ironically, privacy and transparency fears impeded bitcoin adoption. Unless populations are financially literate and trust virtual currencies, policies incentivizing their adoption may fail."
This underscores the importance of established trust and the understanding of societal factors in the successful adoption of new payment technologies.
Comparing Cultural Practices
These cultural practices in payment methods highlight the diversity and adaptability of financial systems worldwide. Each method reflects the unique needs and contexts of its society, demonstrating that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to financial transactions.
Understanding these diverse payment practices not only enriches our appreciation of global financial systems but also underscores the importance of cultural context in shaping financial behavior. As technology continues to advance, it will be fascinating to see how these traditional and unconventional methods evolve and adapt. Whether through trust-based systems like Hundi, cash-centric economies like Germany, or cutting-edge cryptocurrency adoption like El Salvador, the world of payments is a testament to human ingenuity and cultural diversity.
At Payroc, we aim to provide a platform built for partnership ensuring that our solutions are as diverse and adaptable as the payment methods they support. As we look to expand in new markets, we evaluate cultural and logistical factors and how the global economy has influenced our priorities. We consider different types of customer preferences to deliver our omni-commerce solutions, while keeping in line with customer expectations.